Women’s Western Winter Workwear

Some outfits are planned. Others are lived in. 

Caroline’s look sits somewhere in between. It’s built over time, shaped by early mornings, cold arenas, and a life that moves easily between the saddle and the office. Nothing about it feels forced, and that’s exactly why it works. 

Every piece has a purpose. Every layer has earned its place. 

In Episode One of Broken Inn, she walks through what she’s wearing for a bitterly cold horse show day in Montana. The answer is simple. Layers. But not just any layers. These are pieces that have been worn, tested, and trusted through real life. 

Starting from the outside and working in, here’s what that actually looks like.

When temperatures drop into the negatives, layering stops being about style and starts being about function. But when it’s done right, it ends up being both. 

Her Noble Outfitters leather gloves are the first thing she grabs. They’re made from real working leather, the kind that starts out structured and slowly molds to your hands over time. That break-in process matters. It means better grip on reins, more flexibility when working, and protection that doesn’t feel stiff or bulky. You can see the wear on them, and that’s exactly the point. 

With her hands covered, she throws on her Wrangler denim coat, a piece that’s been with her for years. Originally a light wash, it’s faded into a warm, almost tan tone from sun, dirt, and everyday use. That’s the beauty of 100 percent cotton denim. It doesn’t just wear out, it wears in. It holds its structure, softens in the right places, and tells a story the longer you own it. 

The shorter cut of the jacket makes it even more practical. It sits right at the waist, which gives her better mobility when riding or working and keeps everything within reach. It’s not just a good looking coat. It’s one that actually works with her day. 

Underneath, she adds a vest—and this is where the layering really starts to work. A good vest keeps your core warm without restricting your arms, which matters when you’re riding, fixing fence, or doing anything that requires real movement. It’s not the flashiest piece in the outfit, but it’s one of the most important. 

Right now at North 40, we keep coming back to the Smith + Rogue Original Canvas Vest. It’s built with a durable blend of 54% hemp, 14% organic cotton, and 30% recycled polyester, finished with Polartec Power Grid fleece to hold in warmth when the weather turns. The Noble Outfitters Canvas Vest is another solid go-to, made with 100% cotton canvas and a DWR finish for water repellency, plus a soft flannel lining and a faux fur neckline. It’s built to handle harsh conditions without sacrificing comfort.

Some of our favorite coats and vests so you can find your perfect fit

Once you get past the outerwear, this is where the outfit starts to feel more personal. 

Her oversized knit sweater sits right in the middle of everything, softening the structure of the layers around it. It adds warmth without feeling heavy and makes the whole outfit feel easy instead of overbuilt. It’s the kind of piece you end up reaching for without thinking because it just works with everything. For layering like this, the Smith + Rogue Suri sweater is a great option. Made with 83% Alpaca wool, the Suri sweater keeps your core warm while still looking great and layering in a non-bulky way. 

Under that, she wears a Cinch button-down, adding a subtle western-chic element. The key to a great western shirt is being built with a structured material like cotton that holds its shape throughout the day, which makes them ideal for layering. The floral detailing and matching cuffs bring in just enough personality without overpowering the rest of the outfit. Letting the collar and cuffs peek out from under the sweater is a small detail, but it’s what pulls everything together. 

And then there’s the layer doing most of the work. 

Her Smith + Rogue waffle knit Henley is easily the most relied-on piece in the lineup. This is the shirt she keeps going back to, the one she wants to replace everything else with. 

Waffle knit fabric is designed to trap heat while still allowing airflow, which makes it perfect for long days where your activity level is constantly changing. It keeps you warm when it’s cold, but doesn’t overheat once you start moving. The cotton blend gives it durability and softness, while the natural stretch allows it to move with you instead of against you. 

It’s the kind of shirt that works as a base layer, a standalone piece, or something you throw on without overthinking it. She’s worn it through riding, fencing, and everyday life, and even with a hole in the back from barbed wire, it’s still her favorite. That tells you everything you need to know. 

When it comes to long sleeves there are lots of options, pick the combo you feel is right for your style

Finding a good pair of jeans is not easy. Everyone is looking for something a little different, and most pairs don’t quite get it right. But every once in a while, you find one that does, and you don’t let it go. 

That’s exactly what’s happening with her Ariat Perfect Rise jeans. 

Designed with real life in mind, Ariat’s R.E.A.L. Perfect Rise denim balances performance and everyday wear in a way that just works. The rise sits right where most people want it, comfortably at the natural waist without feeling too high or too low. It creates a flattering fit while still allowing you to move, bend, and ride without constantly adjusting your waistband. 

The slim fit through the hips and thighs transitions into a classic boot cut, giving them that timeless western look that fits perfectly over a pair of boots. The performance stretch denim moves with you without stretching out, so you don’t get sagging in the seat or gapping in the back. 

In Episode One, Caroline shows up to her horse show wearing her favorite pair. They weren’t even new when she got them. They were passed down from a friend, already broken in and ready for another round of real life. Since then, they’ve seen plenty of wear. The button has fallen out more than once, and every time she’s just fixed it and kept going. 

That’s what good denim is supposed to do. 

It holds up. It fits right. And eventually, it becomes part of your routine without you even thinking about it.

The R.E.A.L. jeans come in all sorts of sizes and cuts

Some pieces do more than just function. They carry meaning. 

At the center of everything is her belt, finished with a custom Montana Silversmiths buckle from her husband. Montana Silversmiths is known for detailed, handcrafted buckles made with engraved metals and classic western designs, but this one goes beyond that. It’s personal. It’s something she wears every day that connects back to her life outside of work and riding. 

Up top, her Serratelli hat in the cloud color pulls the entire look together. 

A good cowboy hat is one of the easiest pieces to reach for when it’s done right. It has to hold its shape, handle long days outside, and still look good at the end of it. That’s what makes Serratelli such a trusted name in the western world. 

Her hat is a 6X felt, which sits right in that sweet spot between durability and everyday wearability. Felt hats are made by compressing natural fur fibers, often rabbit or beaver, into a dense material that holds its structure over time. Beaver felt, in particular, is known for its ability to resist moisture and maintain shape, which is why it’s considered one of the best materials in hat making. 

The 6X rating typically indicates a blend that includes beaver fur, giving it better longevity and a smoother finish without stepping into the ultra premium range. It’s durable enough for everyday wear, but still refined enough to clean up well when you need it to. 

The cloud color adds a softer, more modern edge while still feeling classic. It’s the kind of hat that works with everything, and once you find one like that, you don’t really switch it out.

Questions about what the X means in Cowboy hats? Check out our full blog here

And then there are the boots. 

Her Hyer boots are not just part of the outfit. They’re part of her life. 

Built with traditional construction methods and full grain leather, they’re designed to last for years and mold to your feet over time. They have the structure needed for riding, with a solid heel and defined spur ledge, but they’re comfortable enough to wear all day without thinking about it. 

They’ve been with her through everything. Engagement, marriage, bringing home a new puppy, long days in the saddle. They’ve been worn, marked, and even chewed on, and somehow that just makes them better. 

At a certain point, boots like that stop being something you wear. They become something that’s undeniably yours.

You can also read about the history of Hyer boots and what makes them so special

What makes this outfit stand out isn’t just how it looks. It’s how it functions. 

Every piece is built for real use. Real leather that breaks in instead of breaking down. Denim that holds its shape and develops character. Layers that regulate temperature and move with you. 

And then there are the personal details. The vest that keeps her warm in brutal weather. The buckle that means something. The boots that have been with her through major life moments. 

Nothing is random. Nothing is overdone. 

It all works because it’s been lived in, not just put together.

Read More about Caroline's Favorites: